Annual estimated out-of-pocket costs for Medicare Advantage Plan members* All Plans below include Medicare Part D-Drug Benefits
RANK	If your health is GOOD use this column Click to see details		If your health is FAIR use this column Click to see details		If your health is POOR use this column Click to see details
#1	Elderplan (Extra) **	$29	Liberty Health Advantage**	$370	Liberty Health Advantage**	$1,020
#2	Touchstone (Power)**	$100	Touchstone (Power)**	$440	Touchstone (Power)**	$2,026
#3	GHI Medicare (PPO Plus) **	$120	GHI Medicare (PPO Plus) **	$490	WellCare (Choice) **	$2,225
#4	Fidelis (Medicare Advantage) **	$124	WellCare (Choice) **	$560	HIP (VIP Medicare) **	$2,526
#5	Healthfirst (65 Plus) **	$130 [Tie]	HIP (VIP Medicare) **	$613	Aetna (Value) **	$2,773
#6	Neighborhood Health (Plus Rx) **	$130 [Tie]	Secure Horizons (AARP 3) **	$637	GHI Medicare (PPO Plus) **	$2,981
#7	AmeriVantage (Classic+Rx) **	$137	Neighborhood Health (Plus Rx) **	$670	Secure Horizons (AARP 3) **	$2,988
#8	Liberty Health Advantage**	$145 [Tie]	Fidelis (Medicare Advantage) **	$846	AmeriVantage (Classic+Rx) **	$3,145
#9	WellCare (Choice) **	$145 [Tie]	Aetna (Value) **	$855	Fidelis (Medicare Advantage) **	$3,187
#10	Comprehensive Care (Value) **	$150	AmeriVantage (Classic+Rx) **	$892	Neighborhood Health (Plus Rx) **	$3,346
#11	HIP (VIP Medicare) **	$155	Elderplan (Extra) **	$1,016	Empire Blue Cross (Plus) **	$3,561
#12	Empire Blue Cross (Plus) **	$183	Healthfirst (65 Plus) **	$1,030	Healthfirst (65 Plus) **	$4,242
#13	Aetna (Value) **	$210	Empire Blue Cross (Plus) **	$1,072	Elderplan (Extra) **	$4,499
#14	Secure Horizons (AARP 3) **	$253	Comprehensive Care (Value) **	$1,565	Comprehensive Care (Value) **	$5,931
	** $0 premium plans		** $0 premium plans		** $0 premium plans
	Average:All Plans	$144	Average:All Plans	$790	Average:All Plans	$3,175

*Annual cost (out-of-pocket expenses) include applicable copayments, deductibles, and premiums. Premiums may vary depending on county of residence. Medicare Part B premium ($96.40 minimum per month in 2009) is not included in cost calculations.

Senior Choice Gold Award recipient for "Excellence in Medicare Benefits Value"
 
The information contained herein is neither guaranteed nor intended to represent actual enrollee experiences for any Medicare plan. Medicare plan benefits, copayments, deductibles, and premiums are subject to change. HealthMetrix Research Inc. does not endorse or recommend specific Medicare plans. COSTSHARE REPORT is a registered mark of HealthMetrix Research Inc.