Please note that this site is a free public service and is not an endorsement for any Medicare health plan or product.

2013 Senior Choice Gold Awards

HealthMetrix Research Selects 2013 Medicare Advantage Plans for Exceptional Benefit Value & Overall Performance

Go to: AL AZ CA CO CT DC FL GA HI IA IL IN KS KY LA MA MD ME MI MN MO NC NJ NM NV NY OH OK OR PA RI SD TN TX UT VA WA WI

SCGA 2011Columbus, Ohio (October 15,2012) - Medicare Advantage plans in 75 cities will be recognized for exceptional value in the design of their medical and Part D prescription drug benefits available for 2013 Medicare plan enrollees.  The 2013 Senior Choice Gold Award recipients were selected from Medicare Advantage plans across 95 cities based on independent cost-sharing comparisons conducted annually by HealthMetrix Research Inc.  and recognition for plans achieving at least 4-star overall ratings for quality and performance as reported by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS).

The award criteria established by HealthMetrix Research Inc. were based on cost-sharing comparisons conducted in each major market.  The comparisons estimate annual out-of-pocket costs based on health status categories (healthy/episodic/chronic) and corresponding utilization of the most common health plan benefits (physician office visits, emergency or urgent care, hospital care, home health visits, prevention care, prescriptions).

HealthMetrix Research Inc. delivers decision-support information to a national audience of managed care organizations, healthcare providers, purchasers, and consumers.  The Senior Choice Gold Award is based on the 2013 Medicare CostShare Report produced by HealthMetrix Research  Inc.  The Medicare CostShare Report methodology and findings have been featured in Medicare Advantage research conducted by George Washington University, Mathematica Policy Research, and Research Triangle Institute.

Medicare Advantage plans receive overall ratings annually on a 1 to 5 star scale.

5 Stars = Excellent Performance
1 Star = Poor Performance

A minimum 3-star rating is required for selection except for plans too new to be rated for 2013.


Denotes "Excellence in Medicare Benefits Value & Performance"



Denotes "Excellence in Medicare Benefits Value"

2013 Senior Choice Gold Award Recipients

Click on the city name to view the 2013 CostShare Report Comparison

State/City Plan

Alabama

 
Birmingham HealthSpring SCGA
Mobile HealthSpring SCGA
Montgomery HealthSpring SCGA

Arizona

 

Phoenix

SCGA

Tucson

SCGA

California

 
Fresno Health Net SCGA

Los Angeles - LA County

Central Health Medicare Plan

SCGA

Los Angeles - Orange County

Central Health Medicare Plan

SCGA

Los Angeles - Riverside County

Citizens Choice

SCGA

Los Angeles - San Bernardino County

Citizens Choice

SCGA
Modesto Care 1st SCGA

Oakland

Easy Choice

SCGA

Sacramento

Blue Shield

San Diego

Easy Choice

SCGA

San Francisco

Care 1st

SCGA

San Jose

Care 1st

SCGA
Ventura

Colorado

 
Colorado Springs

Denver

Connecticut

 

Hartford

WellCare

SCGA

Florida

 

Bradenton

Humana

Fort Lauderdale

Optimum

SCGA

Miami

Humana

Orlando

Preferred Care

Pensacola

Humana

Sarasota

Optimum

SCGA

St. Petersburg

Optimum

SCGA

Tampa

Optimum

SCGA

West Palm Beach

WellCare

SCGA

Georgia

 
Atlanta
Hawaii    
Honolulu Akamai by HMSA
Idaho    
Boise Regence SCGA

Illinois

 

Chicago

Humana

Indiana

 
Fort Wayne Humana SCGA
Iowa    
Des Moines
Kansas    
Wichita

Kentucky

 

Louisville

WellCare

SCGA
Louisiana  
Baton Rouge People's Health SCGA
New Orleans People's Health SCGA
Maine    
Portland Martin's Point
Maryland    
Baltimore

Massachusetts

 

Boston

Michigan

 
Detroit HealthPlus
Grand Rapids Blue Care

Minnesota

 

Minneapolis/St. Paul

Health Partners

Missouri

 
Kansas City

St. Louis

Essence

Montana    
Billings New West SCGA

Nevada

 

Las Vegas

Health Plan of Nevada

SCGA

New Jersey

 

New Jersey (Bergen, Essex, Middlesex, Passaic, Union Counties)

United Healthcare

SCGA

New Mexico

 
Albuquerque Lovelace SCGA
Santa Fe Lovelace SCGA

New York

 

Albany

WellCare

SCGA

Buffalo

WellCare

SCGA

New York City Metro
(Bronx / Kings / Manhattan / Queens / Staten Island)

Easy Choice

SCGA

   Nassau

Health First

SCGA

Rochester

HealthNow

North Carolina    
Raleigh Blue Cross Blue Shield

Ohio

 

Akron

Summacare

Canton

Summacare

Cincinnati

MediGold

SCGA

Cleveland

Summacare

Columbus

MediGold

SCGA
Dayton MediGold SCGA
Toledo Summacare

Oklahoma

 
Oklahoma City Secure Horizons SCGA

Tulsa

Lovelace

SCGA
Oregon    
Portland Humana

Pennsylvania

 
Harrisburg Geisinger

Philadelphia

Health America

Pittsburgh

UPMC

Rhode Island    
Providence United Healthcare SCGA
South Dakota    
Rapid City

Tennessee

 
Chattanooga Healthspring SCGA
Knoxville Healthspring SCGA

Memphis

Healthspring

 

SCGA

Nashville

Healthspring

SCGA

Texas

 

Austin

Humana

SCGA

Dallas

WellCare

SCGA
Fort Worth WellCare SCGA
Utah    
Salt Lake City Select Health SCGA

Virginia

 
Richmond Humana SCGA

Washington

 
Seattle Community Health First SCGA

Washington D.C.

 

Washington D.C.

Wisconsin

 

Milwaukee

United Healthcare SCGA